Social Studies
Objective: I can describe early meetings between Native nations and Europeans from more than one point of view.
Standards: D2.His.4.3-5, D2.His.10.3-5, D2.His.6.3-5
Builds on: Needs Day 1: why explorers and settlers came, and that Native nations already lived here. One-minute check: ask, "Who lived in North America before the ships came?" (Native nations, such as the Taíno.)
- cooperation – working together or helping each other
- conflict – a serious disagreement or a fight
- point of view – how one person or group sees and feels about something
Materials: Notebook, U.S. map, 2 colored pencils, Pencil
- Day 32 — First Meetings: Many Points of View — Big Question Warm-Up · 5 min
Review from Day 1. Ask: "What is the difference between an explorer and a settler?" (An explorer travels to look. A settler stays and builds a home.) Then ask the big question: "Strangers in big ships land near your home. What might you feel? What might they feel?"
- Mini-Lesson · 10–15 min
Find Massachusetts on the map. Say: "In 1620 English settlers landed here and built Plymouth in the homeland of the Wampanoag people." Say: "Helping each other is cooperation. Disagreeing or fighting is conflict." Say: "A Wampanoag leader named Ousamequin made an agreement with the settlers. Each side promised to help protect the other." Say: "A Patuxet man named Tisquantum showed the settlers how to plant corn. He spoke English because an English captain had kidnapped him in 1614. When he got home, sickness had killed most of his village." Say: "Europeans carried sicknesses such as smallpox. Native people's bodies had no protection from them, and very many died." Say: "In Virginia, the Powhatan people traded food to the Jamestown settlers. Later they fought, because settlers kept taking more land." Ask: "Is planting corn together cooperation or conflict?" (cooperation) "Does taking more land lead to cooperation or conflict?" (conflict) Say: "Both peoples are here today. The Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe lives in Massachusetts. The Pamunkey Indian Tribe, part of the Powhatan people, lives in Virginia." If stuck, say: "Helping is cooperation. Fighting or taking is conflict."
- Activity / Source Work · 15–20 min
1) Read Account 1 aloud. William Bradford, the settlers' governor, wrote it. These are his words made simpler. "Squanto showed them how to plant their corn, where to catch fish, and how to get other things they needed. He was their guide to places they did not know." Squanto was the settlers' name for Tisquantum. 2) Read Account 2 aloud. It was written for this lesson from what Wampanoag historians teach today. It is not a paper from 1621. "Strangers built houses in our village fields. Sickness came before them and took many of our people. Our leader made an agreement to protect our nation, but we watched carefully to see if they would keep their word." 3) Read both again slowly. Your child lists helping words with one colored pencil and worry words with the other. (Sample: showed, guide, agreement; strangers, sickness, watched carefully.) 4) Ask: "Bradford was the settlers' governor. How does that explain what he wrote and what he left out?" (He wrote what helped the settlers. He left out how the Wampanoag felt.) 5) Ask: "What evidence shows the Wampanoag were unsure?" ("we watched carefully")
- Notebook Entry · 10 min
Your child draws a T-chart in the notebook: Settler point of view | Wampanoag point of view. Write two ideas on each side. Then finish: "The two groups saw the same events differently because ____." Sample: Settlers were glad for help and needed a guide. The Wampanoag had lost many people and were unsure about promises.
- Wrap-Up & Exit Ticket · 5 min
Read the exit questions aloud. Praise answers that give both sides and use the word "because."
Watch for: Telling this as a simple happy story with one side left out.
Try: After each fact, ask, "How would the other group tell about this same day?"
- Two groups trade food in spring. In fall they fight over a field. Which part is cooperation, and which is conflict?
- Who wrote Account 1? Name one thing he left out, and tell why he left it out.
- In Account 2, why did the leader make an agreement? Why did his people still watch carefully?
Show answers
- Trading food is cooperation. Fighting over the field is conflict.
- William Bradford, the settlers' governor. He left out Wampanoag feelings and losses. He wrote from the settlers' side.
- To protect the nation after sickness took many people. They did not yet know if the strangers would keep their word.
Support: Read one account at a time. After each, ask, "Who is talking? How do they feel?" before any writing.
Extend: Your child writes two questions that each account leaves unanswered. Then name who could answer them, such as Wampanoag historians today.
Homework: Tell a family member the Plymouth story from both points of view. Look for: one helping detail and one worry.
Practice page · Week 7, Day 2
Social Studies
I can describe one event from two points of view.
Two Voices on Manahatta
A Dutch letter from 1626 (real words): "They have purchased the Island Manhattes from the Indians for the value of 60 guilders." Dutch trader, written for this lesson: "We traded goods to the Lenape. Now this island is ours, and we will build a town for trade." Lenape elder, written for this lesson: "We welcomed the traders and shared our island. We thought we were agreeing to let them use the land with us. No one can own the land forever. Now their fences keep us from our fields."
Mark the reading.
- 1.
Underline one sign of cooperation.
- 2.
Circle one sign of conflict or worry.
Fill in the T-chart and answer.
| Dutch point of view | Lenape point of view |
|---|---|
- 3.
What did the Dutch think the deal meant?
- 4.
What did the Lenape think the deal meant?
- 5.
Why did the two groups see the same deal differently?
- 6.
Why did so many Native people get sick after Europeans came?
Challenge: The Lenape still live today. Name one place Lenape nations are based now.
Materials: two colors of pencil